Reputable representatives of Republican Party Congressman Christopher and Smith of House of Representatives diplomatic affairs committee of Congress say: "Secretary of State Clinton says the human rights of protecting the Chinese people can't interfere with economic crisis, climatic change and security question, seem to have nothing to do and connect with the fine long hair of those questions with in human rights " ; Congressman Smith thinks, protects and popularizes the core that human rights should be the so extremely abominable national diplomatic relations of infringing human rights of U.S.A. and China, but not review afterwards.
Congressman of Pennsylvania Republican Party Joseph says skin thatch, this speech of Secretary of State Hilary and Clinton's has sent out an uneasy information to those people who are persecuted under suppressing regime by human rights. Hundreds of millions of Chinese basic human rights is still trampled on, it is still abominable that China's human rights is recorded. The cover thatch is said: "Grievedly, this comment of Secretary of State Clinton's is saying to those warriors fighting for human rights of the whole of China, they just interfere with. "
The cover thatch points out, should not neglect the importance of international human rights because U.S.A. is in economic recession, can't let human rights issue become insignificant certainly. He urges Secretary of State Clinton to emphasize human rights is the same as other countries in U.S.A., the importance especially in the diplomatic relations of China, in order to repair the losses that her speech causes.
The leather thatch was said, he received " the report about the human rights champion high intelligently Sheng " a few days ago ,High Sheng deliver an open letter, records and narrate the cruel persecution that he suffers because of being criticizes Chinese Government intelligently. The cover thatch is said: "During 2007, Gao ZhiSheng is locked up for 50 days, is persecuted by the cruel torture, include hitting his mouth and genitals with the electricity of the electric prod. This kind of behavior is said by Secretary of State Clinton the interference at the time of carrying on on the question of others and negotiating. "
The cover thatch is interrogated: "Over the past 200 years, people living in oppressing in the whole world have been expecting U.S.A. to give them the ideal of encouraging and supporting them all the time, really must we abandon that tradition? "
Reputable Congressmen of Republican Party Frank and Wolff of the committee point out that the House of Representatives of US Congress allocates funds, though the human rights group in U.S.A. has expressed their disappointment and shocked to this, but everybody can guess those bishops of Catholicism imprisoned, teach leader family that persecute, Moslem link clansman, Buddhism Buddhist monk how think of to Hilary silence of Secretary of State.
Frank Wolff quote Martin Luther one famous saying of money " silence itself a signal. Finally, what we remembered is not our what enemy said, but silence of our friend " ; He say " U.S.A. consistent from beginning to end to oppress, persecute, friend of people those that forget. Are not these people our friends now? "
Hilary period of visiting China ( February 21) ,The reason in last century " The counter-revolutionary instigates the crime " Sentenced to the famous personage who is put in prison, now " The overseas joint conference of China's democratic movement " President Wei JingSheng still writes to Hilary, claims " I am a political offender rescued from the Chinese camp at time when a president works as Clinton; I have the honor to be invited to meet with president Clinton in White House; Have the honor to be introduced on the banquet of the Czech president to you by president Harvell too; These political offender and Chinese of that era succoured of ours, all appreciate human rights foreign policies of U.S.A. very much. We succeed in and hail for it, sigh for it insufficiently " . But " see in term of office period, Mr. of Clinton, you made the enormous mistake while being very sorry by we: Break off relations human rights and trade of China, promote Congress pass, administrate favored nation's treatment most, trade of China, by force and then first. Its result is: Have not merely reduce the international prestige of U.S.A., has damaged the democratic undertaking of China, and has brought the calamitous long-term consequence to American's own economy and employment. According to the data that the U.S. government offer, during this period, U.S.A. and trade deficit of China increase between more than 10 times and more than 300 billion dollars rapidly, sum up and is up to more than 20,000 hundred million dollars " .
Wei JingSheng analyzes, the forming of the huge trade deficit to China in U.S.A., the most important one in numerous reasons, but the terms of trade to China are unequal. China is not a market economy country, but the autocratic country of dictatorship of a party: Trade receives the control of the government; Workers have no right to safeguard one's own rights and interests; News medias are all under the controlling of the government. It is exactly the human rights issue, cause the inequality of the terms of trade; Have caused abnormal trade deficit; The ones that have caused economy of developed country are out-of-balance, and even the economic crisis of today. The economic development of the imbalance of China still causes global energy crisis and environmental pollution, cause the global security crisis indirectly too. " whether, discuss human rights issue of China, to prevent government, horse of Palestinian, from solve economy and security efforts of problem " ; "To this behaving appropriately in China of yours, have sent out the criticism of covering the sky and the earth on the Chinese and English websites at home and abroad. This has damaged the image of Palestinian horse's government seriously; Have caused the misunderstanding to the U.S. government seriously; Have attacked the expectations to president Ma of bar of of American masses seriously too " .
Hilary promises after not allowing the worry of human rights to hinder U.S.A. from cooperating with China, Amnesty International " It is shocked to show " . Amnesty International American storehouse agate of subsection say, Hilary's speech makes this global human rights persuade and organize " feel shocked and disappointed extremely " . He says U.S.A. is that a few can oppose one of the countries of China on the human rights topic bravely, Hilary says human rights can't interfere with other important topics, destroys the initiative that U.S.A. protects China's human rights in the future.
But visit China, avoid, discuss human rights topic to Hilary, some Congressman said, believe Hilary can continue human rights issue to pay close attention to the fact China too. Because Hilary tells the media, she will express the concern to human rights before going to Beijing to visit, but can't be interfered to urge the human rights topic to the global economic crisis, global climatic change crisis, and safe crisis. The U.S.A. and China can reach the dialogue understanding each other to go on on each topic.
Reputable Congressman of Democratic Party Lewis of House of Representatives fund raising committee defends Hilary. Lewis says on the 23rd of February, it is believed that Clinton will continue paying close attention to the human rights issue of China. Lewis also says, China should give play to the influence in the Sudan on Dahl's rich crisis. He says: "Recently when I visited in India, I heard the speech about Secretary of State Clinton of news report, but I have not seen personally that says, Hilaries and Is are good friends who has known for a long time from her mouth, I know she cares about human rights issue very much. "
U.S.A. join council, human rights of the United Nations, yet so far, American officer criticize human rights council for violate the United Nations spirit of Declaration of Human Rights once. Lewis says, U.S.A. should become members of the human rights council; Human rights should continue becoming key value of the American foreign policy. "I think the human rights topic should continue becoming heart and soul of the American foreign policy, this is essential. We can't promote the civil rights only in U.S.A., but forget to promote human rights in the whole world. "
U.S.A. " Washington Post " report external world half-and-half fine or not in honest comment that make a speech to Hilary. It is reported, when Hilary visits, her frank, not false diplomatic style that decorate of abundant demonstration. The report quotes Hilary's speech and points out, she does not understand the fierce response of the human rights group, because are clear that it facilitates promoting diplomacy even more than through the artificial diplomatic language that modifies to express.
This newspaper shows in the editorial, more than 50 Americans are imprisoned by China at present, during a visit to China, 12 objection personages are put under house arrest in home at least in Hilary, Hilary's speech has been in fact hit on these objections personage's face for hand. Comment on and point out, Clinton's speech may also represent U.S.A.'s policy to change, this makes people perplex, because the U.S. government in power of two all previous parties both value human rights issue very much, though human rights may not be certain to be all bilateral central topics that talk of the U.S.A. and China each time.
U.S.A. other media point out recently, Chinese Government circumstances in international community is like ice double days such as fire: Wen Jiabao here just acted at the meeting in Davos " Economic the Saviour " Role,indulge in intoxicated with oneself Chinese media still at sense the so enchanted by the scenery as to forget to return; The United Nations human rights council there " Generally review regularly " The mechanism starts, the human rights state of reviewing China and including the special administrative region of Hong Kong and Macro. No matter what a skillful tongue like the reed Chinese representatives are, but face many countries on death penalty, arbitrary to detain and cruel torture, rights and interests ensure, ethnic minority human rights, religious freedom of lawyer, citizen express right and freedom of the press what put forward sharp to address inquires to, and require China to implement the urging sound of " citizen's right and international convention of the political right " as soon as possible, it is unavoidable to be unbearable somewhat.
U.S.A. other media say, completely different from emphasis point of the overseas report, until " whether most countries appreciate achievement, human rights of China, in the past 30 years " Xinhua News Agency , " meeting of the United Nations: Support China to develop the cause of human rights multinationally on behalf of showing " Question, review criticism that meeting meet turn lines of warm chicken soup of stomach this time, and in order to show the human rights state of China is normal, also especially put emphasis on having other countries to accept inquiry together. Only a different one, have, let Xinhua News Agency appear, criticize this " whether other country interfere China internal affairs " intrepid this time Its act.
Former the Communist Party of China Shenzhen propaganda department of municipal Party committee officer, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences special researcher, reside in American famous economist what clear water write articles to point out, in fact, China accepts the United Nations and reviews its legal principle foundation based on human rights treaty to the human rights of China. In the past Chinese ' Including some knowledge one's share) Because does not understand this, criticize " one country regards human rights as the excuse and intervenes China's internal affairs " the official side Statement nearly totally accept. So, it is necessary to introduce the legal principle foundation that other country put forward criticism on China's human rights state.
Up to now, China has already participated in 25 international human rights conventions, there are the key human rights convention among thems <
According to different human rights treaties, the obligation that contracting party undertakes generally includes 4 types, submit the obligation of the report, accept the relevant obligations that Human Right Commission administer, become country accuse of with individual appealing obligationing of target, and attend the obligation about fulfilling judicial judgement in and judicial lawsuit ' Only in the regional human rights treaty according to the regulation) . Outwardly, seem the country only directs while undertaking the obligation against the other countries, but the particularity of human rights has determined the essence obligation that the country undertake on international Human Right Act is not here. Though that concluded the human rights treaty is the country instead of individual, the human rights treaty does not only stipulate the relation between two countries like other treaties, but contracting party " Territory with all people that administer their " . In other words, what international Human Right Act is involved finally is the relation between country and people, the relation between rights and obligations between treaty contracting party of human rights is based on the country and relation between rights and obligations of the man-to-man bet, i.e. every contracting party has rights to require any other contracting party to undertake the human rights obligation, this contracting party is undertaking the same obligation too at the same time.
Country conclude human rights form of treaty across boundaries, but how be to " individual under territory and administration their " under other supervision of country in fact Undertake the question of the obligation - -Understand this, could understand why U.S.A. and other countries have responsibility and pay close attention to and criticize the human rights of China voluntarily. People believe the criticism to China's human rights state about world of the authorities is the propaganda which interfere the internal affairs, because the great majority among them do not understand reason described above.
I think, world criticizes not to " interfere the internal affairs " ,But supervise the implementation concluding a treaty; Since already concluded a treaty, must accept supervision and criticism of contracting party - -China likewise, must exercise right and obligation criticized to other contracting party for to supervise too. Over the last several years, Chinese Government has been expressing all the time that had become " responsible international community members " oneself ,So responsible embodiment, one lies in and fulfils responsibility and obligation for concluding a treaty, second, exercise responsibility, right, obligation that world supervises. " responsible international community members " ,Not responsible when useful to oneself; When it is disadvantageous to oneself, should shoulder the responsibility even more. Signature of treaties international, it used for for shop front or for on try to gain by " country " heavy Interests, but used for undertaking responsibility, exercising the right, doing duty scrupulously.
, to the criticism of China's human rights, the domestic media seems not to dare to report about the international media, this kind of style of holding back unpleasant information is disadvantageous that our country, government, the people are. First of all, the constitution stipulates our country respects and ensures human rights; Secondly, the Party and government in power put emphasis on respecting and ensuring human rights; The most important thing is, people know the current situation of human rights of our country in actual life.
However, U.S.A. is not still the members of the United Nations human rights council now, its Congressman criticizes China's human rights state, lose the basic qualification; And the one that go into exile abroad " Mass movement leader " ,If the state in Israel launches criticizing to China, ingore interests of domestic people, exquisite simply " Human rights " It is unpopular too to require the west to enclose and stop up China.
No comments:
Post a Comment